Process

3 min read

Why every logo we draw starts in pencil

Why every logo we draw starts in pencil

Why every logo we draw starts in pencil

A pencil tip resting on white paper

A screen offers a thousand fonts in a second. Paper offers one line at a time, and that is exactly why we start there.

Every brand we make starts the same way: with a soft pencil, a stack of cheap paper and a rule that nobody opens a laptop for the first three days. It isn’t nostalgia. We’ve tried starting on screen, more than once, and every time the work came out smoother and emptier than it should have.

A screen says yes to everything

The problem with a screen is that it says yes to everything. Type a name, and a hundred typefaces arrive ready-made. Drag a corner and the curve is perfect. That’s wonderful for finishing, and terrible for deciding. When everything looks finished, it’s very hard to tell a good idea from a well-rendered one.

Paper offers one line at a time. A pencil drawing of a mark is honest about how much thinking is in it. If the idea is weak, no amount of polish hides it, because there is no polish. You see the shape, the balance, the one thing that makes it this client’s and nobody else’s, or you see that it isn’t there yet.

Forty drawings before one vector

For Kiln Street Bakery we filled two sketchbooks before anyone touched a computer. Most pages are terrible, which is the point. Drawing fast lets you get the obvious ideas out of your hands early: the wheat sheaf, the rolling pin, the loaf with a smile. Once they’re on paper they stop shouting at you, and the stranger, better ideas have room.

The seal that became their mark appeared on page thirty-one, as a scribble in a margin next to a note about the wax they use on their bread bags. It would never have survived a screen-first process, because on screen it looked like nothing at all. In pencil you could see that it was about the bakery’s own hands.

What the pencil is good for

We’ve found three things that only happen on paper. First, speed: a drawing takes ten seconds, so we make more of them and judge them less. Second, imperfection: a wobbly line shows you where a shape wants to go, and sometimes the wobble is the idea. Third, sharing: a sheet of drawings on the table invites everyone in. A client who would never comment on a vector file will happily point at a sketch and say “that one, but heavier”.

That last one matters more than we expected. The best briefs we’ve had came from clients sitting at our table with a pencil of their own, crossing things out.

When the screen comes in

None of this means we’re against computers. Once a drawing has earned it, it goes on screen and gets drawn properly: curves built point by point, spacing measured, every size tested from a favicon to the side of a van. That stage takes longer than the sketching, and it should. The difference is that by then we’re finishing an idea, not looking for one.

We still keep the pencil nearby. When a curve feels wrong on screen, the quickest fix is often to print it, trace it by hand and scan it back in. The hand knows things the mouse doesn’t.

Try it yourself

If you’re about to start a brand of your own, here is the exercise we give every new person at the table. Take twenty minutes, a soft pencil and a pile of scrap paper. Draw your name thirty times, as fast as you can, without stopping to judge. Then put the pages on the floor and stand over them. You’ll be surprised which ones you like, and even more surprised why.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.