Packaging

3 min read

Twelve cartons and a kettle

A kraft box tied with string and sealed with wax

How a tea company’s packaging went from forty mock-ups to twelve, and why the kettle on our table settled the argument.

Tidewater Tea came to us with forty mock-ups. Their previous studio had been thorough: every tea in the range had its own box, its own colour and, in a few cases, its own typeface. Laid out on our long table they looked like a party where nobody had been introduced.

Forty boxes, one shelf

The trouble with packaging is that it never lives alone. A box that looks wonderful on a screen sits on a shelf next to eleven of its siblings and forty competitors. What we needed wasn’t a better box. It was a family that looked like a family from across the shop, and still let you find your own tea in a second.

So we did something unglamorous. We bought every box on the shelf of the shop next door, carried them back, and lined them up under the same light. Then we put Tidewater’s mock-ups among them and walked to the far end of the room. From there, you couldn’t find Tidewater at all.

Twelve cartons

We cut the range to one carton shape and one lettering style, and let colour do the work. Every blend got a hand-lettered name, drawn in pencil first, and a colour taken from the tea itself: we brewed each one, photographed the cup, and matched the ink to it. The breakfast tea is the brown of strong tea with a dash of milk. The green tea is the pale gold of a second steeping.

We made twelve physical cartons, folded by hand, and lived with them for a fortnight. Some went in the kitchen, some went on the shelf at the shop, one went home with Wout and came back with a coffee ring on it, which told us more about the stock than any spec sheet.

The kettle

The argument that settled everything happened at the kettle. We had two finalists for the carton stock: a bright white board that printed the colours beautifully, and an uncoated, slightly grey board that dulled them a little. On screen the white won easily. Next to a steaming kettle, the white board started to curl and the colours looked loud. The grey board stayed flat and looked like it had always been there.

Tidewater picked the grey one. The colours are a touch quieter, and the cartons feel like something you keep rather than something you throw away.

What changed

The range has since grown from twelve teas to eighteen without a single new template: a new blend gets a new name, a new colour and the same carton. The shop now refills tins and cartons over the counter, which wasn’t part of the brief and is the thing the founders talk about most.

The lesson we took away is simple and slightly boring. Packaging decisions belong in the room where the packaging will be used. Bring the kettle.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.